PDA

View Full Version : Brookies And A Little Something Extra



spilunkr
04-11-2005, 07:28 AM
I finally got my first chance of the year to get out for some native brookies over the weekend. I didn't want to stray to far from home so I just headed up to my favorite little stream the Catoctins.

http://im1.shutterfly.com/procserv/47b5da31b3127cce91406c319bb700000026109AZM2bZu2ba

Being that it was such a gorgeous weekend there were lots of people out, hiking, mountain biking, rock climbing and fishing. But fortunately, my favorite stretch of stream was void of fishermen. The stream was a bit high but crystal clear. Parking the car I rigged up my outfit of choice for the day. This brookie season would start with a bow toward tradition; 7' 4wt. split cane rod, a 1909 Pfluger Progress brass reel and Cortland's new imitation silk fly line.

Stepping into the stream it wasn't long before the first fish hit my little coachman...........missed him, and so it went for the first three risers. As usual, first time out, the timing was a little off. Finally after about 10 minutes a solid hook up to a fat little brookie. I wonder what he'd been feeding on?

http://im1.shutterfly.com/procserv/47b5da31b3127cce91406cf81a4e00000026109AZM2bZu2ba

Over the course of the next three of hours, it was never more than a few minutes between hookups. Most of the fish were in the 6" to 7 1/2" range. However. it was good to see a fair number of fish in the 8" to 10" range, a size that has been pretty much absent for the last two years due to the drought conditions in 2001/2002. In fact this guy, a nice hook jawed 10" male, was the nicest brookie I've caught on this stream in 3 years. He definitely put a nice bend in my little cane rod.

http://im1.shutterfly.com/procserv/47b5da31b3127cce91406df1dbef00000026109AZM2bZu2ba

After about three hours of catching brookies, I decided to move over to a stocked stream to try for a couple fish for dinner. But, since the stream also has a some brookies, I rigged up a wooly bugger for the stocked fish and a coachman wetfly dropper just in case. This stream is considerably larger both in stream width and volume of water.

http://im1.shutterfly.com/procserv/47b5da31b3127cce91406dfbdbe500000026109AZM2bZu2ba

Even though this stream had been open for three weeks there were still a number of people fishing, so it took awhile to find an open stretch of water. After a half dozen casts, I was hooked up to a 6" bookie on the dropper. Moving up to the next pool, I hooked a 9" rainbow which got off before I could land it. Next couple pools nothing but a couple taps from some small brookies. The next pool was a good sized pool with a four foot water fall at the head and backed up by a debris dam at the tail. It was deep enough that the bottom could not be seen. Third drift through the pool, my line just stopped dead. Lifting up on the rod nothing happened leading me to think I was hung on the bottom. A couple of jerks and the line slowly drifted in the current toward the log jam. As I increased the pressure to keep whatever I was snagged on from getting into the debris and loosing my two flys there came a head shake and an airborn fish. At that point my jaw dropped and I thought, I hope he dosn't break my rod.

http://im1.shutterfly.com/procserv/47b5da31b3127cce91406de7dbf900000026109AZM2bZu2ba

The rainbow measured a tad over 18". A couple times when he got into the current, my rod was bent over double trying to keep him out of the log jam. Did I also mention that he was hooked on 6x tippet which meant no room for trying to horse him across the current. I was extremely lucky he never got into the log jam at the pool tail. If you noticed in the picture the reel is held on with a traditional slip ring; well it was the first time I've used this reel and the fit wasn't very tight and halfway throught the fight the reel fell off. Through blind luck, I felt it fall off and made a reach for it and it fell into my left hand instead of the pool. Somehow I managed to keep the fish under control with my right hand and finger pressure on the line while I put the reel back on the rod with my left hand and after about 10 minutes manged to net him as he drifted by in the current.

The last hour of fishing was considerably more ordinary, no more rainbows but another half dozen brookies on the wet fly dropper.

As far as I was concerned, it was a dynamite way of starting off spring.

Guy

AlexT
04-11-2005, 08:04 AM
What a pig of a rainbow!!! Amazing story Guy. And what a day to be on water like that to boot.

Given the reports I think yesterday made up for weeks of rain in terms of fishing quality and a gorgeous day.

riverwade
04-11-2005, 08:10 AM
Sweet. What a way to start the season. Where did you find that old reel? Ebay? That's pretty cool. Nice job.

djones
04-11-2005, 08:13 AM
Such an outstanding report, I almost don't know where to start. Ok, I 'll start with the tackle. What did you think of this line? I'm also curious about the rod and reel.

I was enjoying the pictures of the brookies and their steam, and then my eyes widened when I scrolled to the big rainbow. Wow, "something extra" sums it up. I going to have to reread this detail (hell, I'll probably reread the whole post multiple times). I can imagine how you felt, but imaging it and experiencing are, of course, vastlly different.

You're the man, Guy.

paxfish
04-11-2005, 08:27 AM
Guy - Great story, Thanks.

I've always looked at those reel seats with suspicion. There's a million stories of success with them I'm sure, but it just ain't right.

spilunkr
04-11-2005, 08:40 AM
Riverwade,

I've actually had that reel for about 15 years. I have about a dozen antique reels, but this is the only one that old that still works - right down to the drag. I bought it at the Easton Waterfowl Festival in the building which is mostly like a flea market in that is has almost anything to do with hunting or fishing. At the time I think I paid about $20 for it. Over the winter I decided to clean it up really well and put a line on it.

Doug,

After seeing what the price of actual silk lines has done I was pleased to see Cortland "tradtional" product line. It is called a 444 "Sylk" line. It has the diameter of a comparable silk line and is designed to look and cast like a traditional silk line but is made with modern materials. It really worked very well on the rod at the distances I was casting - 10' to 25'. I have not yet tried longer casts.

Guy

HJS
04-11-2005, 08:45 AM
Sounds like a very memorable trip. Heck, that rainbow was bigger than all the hickories I caught on sunday!!!

OneMoreCast
04-11-2005, 09:01 AM
Nice Guy... that brookie is a pig!!!
Jamie and I should have headed to the mountains..the bay is a sewer...

spilunkr
04-11-2005, 09:08 AM
Tony,

One nice thing about this area is there is almost always someplace to fish. The above average rainfalls of the past 2 1/2 years has made for some of the best trout stream flows in the 30 years I've lived here. The brookies were everywhere in the stream I was fishing.

Guy

Ladyfish
04-11-2005, 09:15 AM
Awesome! The brookies were gorgeous; but the rainbow is just..well, awesome!

Montcopo
04-11-2005, 09:24 AM
Very nice report. It gets my juices flowing!! Love the rod and reel selection. I use my 7'0 4 wt cane on brookie waters and it makes for a perfect combination. You had a great day well spent. Congrats.

noke41
04-11-2005, 09:36 AM
Guy-
What a day! Tony sumed up our weekend fishing outing...We should have headed west! Those fish a pigs! I am glad you got into them!!
Jamie

Ken Tidy
04-11-2005, 10:00 AM
Way to go there Guy, sounds like you had a great day of fishing!

Cutter
04-11-2005, 10:28 AM
Too cool. Congrats.

McFly
04-11-2005, 11:51 AM
Guy,
Love it... you are the man of the Catoctin Mt. streams!

I believe your observations on the health of the brookie fishery there are accurate. Perhaps you should pass information to MD DNR since they recently were trying to assess this fishery and its economic importance... then again, maybe you shouldn't tell anyone...[wink]

So did that 'bow suffice for "... a couple fish for dinner.'' ?

I've been wondering if the high water/rough start to the put/take season will result in more 97 larger) holdover trout this year... at least further into the summer.

spilunkr
04-11-2005, 12:26 PM
Charlie,

I think I made that comment about the drought impacts on the DNR survey last year. But I think what the survey was trying to do was get a handle on the number of people who fish for brookies and the economic impact of the fishery; i.e. given insufficient funding for fisheries programs can spending money on brookies be justified.

I can't speak for other streams, but the reason I went looking for a couple fish to take home was because I thought that the high water events since stocking might have spread the fish out more than normal and kept the number of fishermen down. Based on what I found, I think the stream was picked pretty clean.

As far as dinner, one like that is definitely suffices as dinner for two.

Guy

Marcel_Karssies
04-11-2005, 01:24 PM
Nice to see that you did so well on the stream.
The brookie is very high on my to do list but unfortunately
they are not stocked anywhere near why I live.
They seem to be a favourable fish in Alpine streams and Lakes from Bavaria to Austria.

The German club I am member of used to have brookies
in the good old days when people could catch dozens of
trout a day due to intensive stocking.

How deep is the river you fished? It looked so shallow although
I know from expirience that even very little shallow streams can
have surprisingly deep pools (think going for a swim:).

OneMoreCast
04-11-2005, 01:29 PM
Marcel...I'll let Guy fill in the blanks but just an fyi...those brookies are all natives. It is an awesome fishery.

McFly
04-11-2005, 01:31 PM
Guy,

UR right about the survey... I wonder what the final results were? If they determined there was an economic benefit, what would they do to help wild brook trout? One might conclude from your observations that if substantial sections of streams simply remain clean and undisturbed by development, the brookies will take care of themselves, even through drought periods.

I'm not surprised if the stockers are mostly gone already. Though I have not since living in MD, I wouldn't hesitate to keep one or two each spring... no way I'm going to join the opening day crowds though. I really wish MD would follow VA and do away with "seasons".

fisham
04-11-2005, 02:26 PM
Nice job.

spilunkr
04-11-2005, 02:36 PM
Marcel,

Most of the brook trout streams I fish in this area are pretty small. The stream in the first picture averages about 3 meters wide and a couple of the streams I fish are so small, I can frequently stand with one foot on each bank. As you might guess, they also tend to be very shallow, again I have fished the stream in the first picture in mid summer and not gotten wet over my ankles. The deeper pools on this stream are usually not much more than mid thigh in depth.

The stream in the second picture is more typical of the "larger" mountain brookie streams in western Maryland or down in Shenandoah National Park in Virginia. It averages 5 to 6 meters across. Pools are generally deeper on average and occassionally you will find pools with a small surface area but which very deep. I know one pool on the Rose River in SNP where a 4 meter high waterfall drops into a pool that is no more than 3 meters wide by 10 meters long. I could not see the bottom of the pool but there was a tree trunk that had come over the falls during a highwater event that was sticking straight up in the pool and I could follow the bark pattern on the trunk down to a depth of about 3 meters before it just got to fuzzy to see any deeper.

The log jam that backed up the pool in which I caught the big rainbow was over a meter in height. I could not see the bottom of this pool but had no problem seeing the bottom in other pools that were between 1 and 2 meters deep. I'm guessing that pool was probably a bit over 2 meters at its deepest point which happened to be the just off the edge of the boulder I was standing on.


Charlie,

I don't think that going to the year 'round no closed season stocking program like VA and WVA would make much difference for the first couple of stockings in the spring. People know when the truck shows up and the streams are pounded for the next couple of weeks. I've seen that in VA and my assistant lives in WVA and says the same thing happens there.

I've not seen any results from the DNR survey either. As you probably know, most MD brookie streams fall under the general two trout per day regulation. I don't think that will change as they seem to be able to tolerate current levels of fishing pressure. Almost all of the brookie streams I fish are in some kind of public ownership so development per se is not likely; acid mine drainage, acid precipitaiton and logging are the biggest threats that I see. DNR has some lime dosers on a couple of brookie streams in Garrett Co. although I think they were put in more to benefit Jennings Randolph Reservoir than the brookie streams.

Guy